BBI JU flagship projects - The new generation of European advanced biorefineries
The flagship is the main vessel of a fleet. It
carries the flag of the commander indicating the route to follow. The BBI JU
reserves this designation for a special kind of prominent projects that has the
potential to lead the European bioeconomy to the next level. While I was reading
the new Strategic Innovation and Research Agenda (SIRA) of the Bio-based
Industries Consortium (BIC) to prepare a recent post, I realised how important they are for the
creation of a new generation of advanced biorefineries, So, I decided to write
a post explaining the concept and introducing briefly the flagship projects
funded so far.
One of the main priorities of the BBI JU is bringing
sustainable technologies to maturity through R&D and demonstration
activities. The work done to date is really impressive: 36 running projects +
29 starting from call 2016 giving a total of 65 projects. 6 of those 65 are
flagships. What are their common characteristics?
- They mainly involve demo activities corresponding to TRL 8 (system complete and qualified).
- They support the launch of an innovation that has been demonstrated but not yet deployed on the market.
- They include the establishment of a first-of-a-kind, large-scale facility. This may be a new plant, a substantially remodelled existing facility or a reconverted old or abandoned industrial facility.
- They cover a complete value chain: procurement, growth and supply of feedstock; biomass conversion via biorefining into biobased chemicals and materials; market up-take of end products.
Figure 1. Correspondence between BBI JU actions
and TRL (extracted from SIRA 2017)
The earmarked funds for these projects are very
high as building and running first-of-a-kind plants entails significantly
higher costs and risks than demonstration plants because of the increased
scale. Moreover, they have significantly higher costs and higher risks than
subsequent commercial plants which benefit from a learning curve and better
financial terms.
According to the SIRA, the objective for
2020 is to sign at least 5 flagship grant agreements between the BBI JU and
project consortia. Currently, this milestone is already achieved. Even,
it is supposed that a sixth flagship has been signed under 2016 call. I tried
to look up this flagship in CORDIS (Community Research and Development
Information Service). At the time of writing this post, there are 28 projects
registered and they should be 29. 1 project is still missing and it is a flagship.
NOTE 1: This information will be updated if the
sign of the sixth flagship is unveiled.
The first version of the SIRA specified 1
flagship for each of the 5 reference value chains to be developed by the
programme. In fact, an example for every value chain was described in the
document. The following table summarizes those descriptions.
Value Chain (VC)
|
VC flagship example
|
|
From lignocellulosic feedstock to advanced
biofuels, biobased chemicals and biomaterials
|
VC1
|
Advanced
biofuels, biobased chemicals and energy from 400,000 dry tons of straw.
|
The next
generation forest-based value
chains
|
VC2
|
Production
of innovative pulp fibres for textiles at a volume of 200,000 ton/y from wood,
coproducing new bio-based products at 20,000 ton/y.
|
The next
generation agro-based value chains
|
VC3
|
Processing
of agricultural green or lignocellulosic residues and surplus into 100,000
ton/y of proteins and valuable chemicals and materials.
|
Emergence
of new value chains from organic waste
|
VC4
|
Conversion
of 400,000 tons of straw, 650,000 tons of manure and 50,000 tons of MSW into
73 Ml of bioethanol and about 99 Mm3 of biogas. In addition,
district heating for approx. 10-20,000 households and electricity equivalent
to 15-25,000 households’ consumption will be produced.
|
The
integrated energy, pulp and chemicals biorefineries
|
VC5
|
Conversion
of an energy plant that currently co-fires 1,000,000 ton/y of biomass for
energy production, into an integrated biorefinery producing 400,000 ton/y
cellulose fibres and chemicals next to bioenergy.
|
This was the starting point. The current
reality is reflected in the tables below. 2014 and 2015 calls numbered its
topics with a link to the specific value chains mentioned in the SIRA 2013.
However, in order to promote the cross-sectorial integration along and across
value chains, this link disappeared from 2016 call. This is the reason to
introduce two separated tables. There is one empty row waiting for the eventual
confirmation of one flagship more.
Value Chain
|
Project
|
Call
|
Feedstock and processing capacity
|
Products and production capacity
|
Location
|
Coordinator
|
BBI JU contribution
|
VC1 (lignocellulose)
|
2015
|
Agricultural
residues (600 kton) in combination with dedicated energy crops to be grown on
marginal lands (320 kton).
|
1st
stage: 2G ethanol (55 kton).
2nd
stage: 2G ethanol (110 kton); bioethylene;
other products from sidestreams.
|
Brownfield
industrial site in the eastern part of the Slovak Republic.
|
Biochemtex
(Italy).
|
21,568,195
€
|
|
LIGNOFLAG
|
2015
|
Straw.
|
2G
ethanol (60 kton); biochar from lignin; fertilizer from sludge.
|
-
|
Clariant
(Germany).
|
24,739,430
€
|
|
VC2
(forest-based)
|
EXILVA
|
2015
|
Cellulose
fibres.
|
Microfibrillated
cellulose (1 kton).
|
Sarspborg
(Norway).
|
Borregaard
(Norway).
|
27,433,610
€
|
VC3 (agro-based)
|
2014
|
Underutilized
oil crops (cardoon) grown in arid and/or marginal lands.
|
Pelargonic
and azelaic acids (10 kton each); biodegradable esters (20 kton).
|
Sardinia
(Italy).
|
Novamont
(Italy).
|
16,995,882
€
|
Project
|
Call
|
Feedstock and processing capacity
|
Products and production capacity
|
Location
|
Coordinator
|
BBI JU contribution
|
PEFerence
|
2016
|
-
|
FDCA (50
kton).
|
BASF’s
Verbund site in Antwerp (Belgium).
|
Synvina (Netherlands)
|
24,999,610
€
|
AgriChemWhey
|
2016
|
25 ktons (100% dry
matter) of whey permeate (WP) and delactosed
whey permeate (DLP).
|
l-Lactic acid,
polylactic acid, minerals for human nutrition and biobased fertiliser.
|
Ireland
| Glanbia Ingredients (Ireland) |
22,007,931 €
|